←
Sam Tobin-Hochstadt44,600 posts
Sam Tobin-Hochstadt avatar

Sam Tobin-Hochstadt

@samth

Associate Professor, @IULuddy · Core Developer, @racketlang · Member, @TC39 · Handler, @gravemaker_ulti · @samth@types.pl

◷ Joined October 2008▧ 969 Photos and videos
Jessica Hullman avatar
⟳ Sam Tobin-Hochstadt retweeted
Jessica Hullman@JessicaHullman·Nov 17

I recently became aware of how confused even many academics are about Pangram. Please, please, look at the audits that have been done before you deliberately sow doubt. (link in thread)

Post attachment
Aaron Freedman avatar
⟳ Sam Tobin-Hochstadt retweeted
Aaron Freedman@freedaaron·Nov 17

Don’t worry there’s plenty of blame to go around: neoliberal climate politics and left climate politics have both been colossal failures!

Sam Tobin-Hochstadt avatar
Sam Tobin-Hochstadt@samth·Nov 16

The key data structure in Racket's macro expander is the _set of scopes_; that's how identifiers know their binding, and macro hygiene avoids capture. Currently, it's represented as a (persistent) set of opaque scope tokens. But I've always thought there must be something better.

Sam Tobin-Hochstadt avatar
Sam Tobin-Hochstadt@samth·Nov 16

CS Academia has two factions: those in denial about the value of bean counting, and those unwilling to explicitly promote bean counting. Thus nothing changes and everyone us confused about why.

i’m increasingly of the opinion that almost everyone agrees with this, but a big fraction of people aren’t comfortable saying it in public, because of what it implies for the bean counting mechanism the whole machine is built on (for awards/promo/hiring/etc).

Halvar Flake avatar
⟳ Sam Tobin-Hochstadt retweeted
Halvar Flake@halvarflake·Nov 16

There's an argument to be made that the hardware/systems/OS/runtime folks have failed projects like FFMpeg by not providing good mechanisms that ensure ffmpeg is sandboxed everywhere.

FFmpeg's complaints are invalid. They don't care about writing secure code. They don't care that somebody can send you a video file that takes control of your machine. They are like every other "vendor" of software that doesn't care about the security of their code and who looks for reasons to pretend the vuln finders are the bad guys. The person finding a vulnerability in your code isn't the one who created it. I say this as somebody who has analyzed many bugs in FFmpeg. The code is inherently broken and unfixable. For example, one bug I looked at allocated a buffer in one library, using one algorithm to calculate its size, and then filled in the buffer in another library, using a completely different algorithm to calculate its size. Obviously, there was a size mismatch. The fix isn't to change the calculations to come up with the same size, but to carry bounds information with the buffer, so that the code filling in the buffer knows the buffer size, and can check it against an accidental overflow. Since these were different libraries, this requires a change in the API -- something no outside vuln researcher can do, something only a core maintainer can do. FFmpeg cannot be fixed without a major redesign of its API to carry bounds information. FFmpeg code is neither secure nor securable because they don't care ab out security. Google's vuln researchers didn't create this problem. FFmpeg has 1 person generating insecure code faster than 1000 vuln researchers can keep up pointing out problems.

Sam Tobin-Hochstadt avatar
Sam Tobin-Hochstadt@samth·Nov 15

If you're unhappy about Project Zero finding bugs in your C code, just declare it untrusted and build everything with Fil-C or in a Wasm container. It's 2026 and you should already have a plan for avoiding C + untrusted input.

I get what Google is trying to do, but I don't agree with it at all. Sure, there are some vendors who just sit on bugs forever and don't make any effort to patch them. But there's way more overworked & underpaid teams, non-profits, and solo projects who are patching bugs as fast as they physically can. The number of CVEs found in 2026 is double that of 2025, so double the workload for anyone doing security fixes. Then on top of that, reducing the disclosure time from 90 to 60 days gives them 2/3 of the time to do double the work. At some point the dam is going to break. You have vulnerability researchers and AI companies burying software maintainers under an endless torrent of bug reports, while doing little to nothing to help with actually fixing the bugs. Eventually, the software maintainers are just going to burn out and give up.

Sam Tobin-Hochstadt avatar
Sam Tobin-Hochstadt@samth·Nov 9

Not really a fan of our city being a laughingstock for genuinely 0 gain. Not a good move by the council.

MTS@MTSliveNov 8

SITUATION DETECTED: Bloomington, Indiana's city council voted unanimously this week to ban any recursively self-improving entity capable of greatly outperforming all humans on all cognitive tasks from inside city limits, citing existential hazards and loss of human control.

Senate Majority PAC avatar
⟳ Sam Tobin-Hochstadt retweeted
Senate Majority PAC@MajorityPAC·Nov 4

No one mourns the wicked!!

0:27
Sam Tobin-Hochstadt avatar
Sam Tobin-Hochstadt@samth·Nov 7

It's depressing that after all of the awfulness of the IN GOP, some people think the thing that did them in was trying to have good housing policy.

The flagship example here is Indiana House Speaker Todd Huston, who lost his seat. He represents upscale suburban Fishers. He promoted multiple pieces of legislation this year, at the behest of lobbyists, that I'm confident the vast majority of his own constituents opposed. First was HEA 1001 - the bill number shows it was his signature legislation of that term. The original bill would have abolished single family zoning statewide. Do you think his constituents wanted that? It was a overall vast attempt strip local governments of land use control that was fortunately mostly hollowed out. But make no mistake, he was promoting this. Second was HEA 1210, which preempted local caps on rental units in subdivisions, including the one in Fishers. (It also overrode some Carmel short term rental rules and made it harder for HOAs to limit rentals). Huston didn't vote on the bill, but as Speaker, it doesn't even get a vote unless he says so. Do you think his constituents want their subdivisions being turned over into mostly rentals? I don't think so. This is a good example of how the Indiana GOP is too often owned and controlled by lobbyists, to the point that they will push through legislation their own constituents hate. No wonder this guy lost!

Sam Tobin-Hochstadt avatar
Sam Tobin-Hochstadt@samth·Nov 7

If you get a suspicious looking email that seems to be from my email address, it is suspicious and you should delete it.

Sam Tobin-Hochstadt avatar
Sam Tobin-Hochstadt@samth·Nov 6

There's an interesting point here about getting different kinds of students to read, but the critiques of Hatchet offered in the article all seem very weak. Humans facing the immensity of the natural world is a classic theme of literature.

The first novel I ever loved was the survival classic Hatchet, but recently I’ve learned that a *lot* of women despise this book, and see it is as something they were forced to read in school to entice the idiot illiterate boys in their English class. I dove into that tension!

Post attachmentPost attachmentPost attachmentPost attachment