
3/3 If providing a platform legitimates what is said, universities must presumably legitimate every proposition advanced in their lecture theatres, seminar rooms and classrooms. Including all the propositions that directly contradict one another.

Trying to do better

3/3 If providing a platform legitimates what is said, universities must presumably legitimate every proposition advanced in their lecture theatres, seminar rooms and classrooms. Including all the propositions that directly contradict one another.

2/3 Nor does the university's decision to organise the seminar. The intellectual legitimacy of what is said depends on the content, not on who provides the platform. Arguments have to stand on their own two feet.

1/3 We need to challenge the lazy locution: "Giving it a platform legitimates it." FFS. When I attend a university seminar at which nonsensical or intellectually shoddy things are said, my presence does not legitimate them.

I spoke to Susan Pickard and Sandra Walklate for their new Saving Sociology podcast. We discussed my rather accidental route into sociology, what the discipline is for, and why standards of evidence and methodological rigour matter. savingsociology.substack.com…

UCL once had a Cyril Burt prize which as one wit quipped, went to the u/g who did the best job of faking their data.
Just got an email from UCL inviting students to apply for the “Jason Arday Student Success Legacy Award.” £150 for a project that must focus on "reducing awarding gaps" and improving the experience of underrepresented groups — especially Black and neurodivergent students. They want us to “continue his legacy” of kindness and inclusion. Lol. Lmao, even.

A peaceful protest is a legitimate expression of free speech. A mob preventing people going where they want to go on a public street is not. The mob should have been arrested.

Actually, probably intended consequences by some of the advocates.
Baroness Hilary Cass tells committee considering draft Conversion practices Bill that she cannot support it as stands. She saw the Bill 15 mins before Gov wanted press statement signed off. "Having obviously spent a long time now thinking about it, I unfortunately I don't think it is anywhere near tight enough to avoid serious unintended consequences."

This made me laugh out loud. I have a sister ….
SNL is patchy but when it’s good…

"Love your enemies and pray for those who persecute you" seems to have gone out of fashion with this former member of the General Synod.
Jayne Ozanne neatly demonstrating how easily the "harm" threshold in the draft Conversion Practices Bill is reached when the "victim" is someone who cannot tolerate viewpoints that differ from theirs

🧵 The replies just pile up the evidence for the point Rob is making. If you are not in power or sharing power the policies you held dear that left you in that position are just expensive moral theatre.
I’m starting to wonder if the fate of electoral reform may now hinge on the fate of the Greens’ “Zionism is racism” motion. These may not seem inherently related so bear with me 1/? politicshome.com/news/articl…

The obvious thing to do is for the 49 to go to Cofnas' talk & in the Q & A challenge him with the evidence & argument they mention. Isn't that how it works?
Today, 49 members of the Oriel College Senior Common Room published a statement, in a personal capacity, on the Nathan Cofnas event on 17 November. I am one of the signatories. Full statement here docs.google.com/document/u/0…

5/14 Here the hyperbole is the point. Human rights language is being mobilised to defend the entitlement of male athletes to compete in female sport.

« La plupart des hommes et en particulier les intelligents euh… les intellectuels préfèrent leur représentation du monde à la réalité. Accepter la réalité est au fond désagréable. » Raymond Aron

Laughed so hard at this

disinterested investigation of empirical questions is not possible, everyone has an angle, the truth is a matter of opinion and so forth. Once that takes hold, universities are just another hustler in a world of alternative "facts".

Senior academics defending the indefensible is an unedifying sight. But it is not merely an eccentric aberration. It threatens public trust in the academy. And that is incredibly dangerous in a world where all sorts of ideologues have an interest in spreading the view that